With Growth comes Challenges. - Latest challenge >> Plagiarization !

in Foodies Bee Hive4 months ago

Its been a great ride for Foodies ever since its inception. The community has grown in leaps and bounds and the overall growth of the Hive chain has been reflected in Foodies as well.

pexels-andrea-piacquadio-3755755.jpgPhoto by Andrea Piacquadio from Pexels

However, with growth comes new members, new opportunities and also importantly new challenges. We don’t see these challenges as a negative, however we do see them as things to be solved.

The challenges plagiarization is one such serious problem. We tried various soft methods such as gently hinting at the offending parties via comments, warning them and even down voting some content. However, these soft methods have met with limited success. Off late the problem has reached epic proportions. A level where the credibility of the community as a place for original content or content with proper sourcing is at stake.

Now we can’t have that! Can we?

So here is what we are going to do as a community! We will implement a series of steps of discourage this practice and if need be weed out such users from our community by imposing costs on such actions.

Here are the steps we will be implementing : -

1- First time offenders gets warned by our curators in the comments section of the plagiarized post. If the user is the original owner of the content able to establish the source as their own they can reply to the same comment thread, with established source link and the post will be deemed as original.

Users who attempt to hide the warning comments will be seen as THIRD time OFFENDERS. (See point 3).

2- If the user ignores this first warning and continues on the same path. The next such post will be considered as 2nd offense. Second time offenders go on a watch list maintained by the curators. The same will be communicated to them via a comment on their post. Once someone is on the list every post by that user is now subject to scrutiny.

3- If they still don't mend their ways, After the 3rd such post they will be considered 3rd time offenders. Third time offenders will be muted on the Foodies channel. Their tendency to rip stuff off the net will be brought to notice of curators of every other major communities on Hive such as OCD and Gems etc.

4 Users banned in such a manner can appeal the same in “moderation” channel of Foodies Discord. The curation team will arrive at a consensus on the future course of action with respect to the individual offender. The same will be communicated to the offending user. The user is expected comply in case they wish to continue being a part of the Foodies community.

5 Once the user has completed whatever actionable the foodie’s curation team may have imposed on them. They can be considered for re-integration in the community.

6 In case of repeat offense after this, Which is a 4th time offense. They will be permanently banned from Foodies. The same will be informed to all other hive communities. They will also be reported to Hivewatchers and Hivespammers.

As you can see, we have tried to take as lenient an approach as possible, however we intent to compensate for the leniency by implementing the above mentioned steps with great prejudice and no exceptions.

Lets hope we don't need to walk down that path. Everyone understands its not easy to cook something up everyday. However, the potential to create content on food as a whole with good research and information is literally limitless. Lets stick to that. Lets endeavor to make this a community that perhaps can one day become the defacto Food Site of Web 3.0.

Warm Regards
Foodies

Sort:  

It's very sad, but a common thing in many communities, unfortunately. I hope these new clear rules will ban out most of the authors that plagiarize. Hopefully, soon it will be less of a challenge to take action against them as they slowly disappear :)

They will never disappear, on the contrary, with mass adoption we're going to get more. People are used to share whatever they want, just to get some likes. This is not a place like that.

Congratulations @foodiesunite! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You received more than 1000 HP as payout for your posts and comments.
Your next payout target is 2000 HP.
The unit is Hive Power equivalent because your rewards can be split into HP and HBD

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

It is a serious matter in the writing and blogging world, however, stating specific community rules is the best way to combat plagiarization

I couldn't agree more!

I await another post from you

Vaya.! Que malo eso del plagio. 😥

Y si, es complicado cocinar algo diferente diariamente, sin embargo, cuando algo te gusta... Las ideas surgen repentinamente, y dices: Manos a la obra, aún hay día.! 🙌

Saludos, espero puedan controlar esos usuarios. Me pongo también a la orden, para cualquier eventualidad en que pueda ayudarles.

Maravilloso sábado. ! ☺️

untitled.gif

What a great initiative I have to say finally because we saw them ( we all know them by now ) drop the links like it were chocolate sprinkles. I think it’s a good step to the right path. We will watch the list closely aswell and bling and cooking is life essential so take a picture while cooking and make a great blog.

So thank you

You're too lenient. I don't see why allow them to have three attempts. We're adults, stealing is punishable by law, it should not be thought here. One should know from home not to take what is not theirs.

Mute them to have this place clean. Mass adoption will bring a lot of plagiarizers as well, the sooner we send a strong message, the better. This is our home, let's keep it clean!

Thanks for what you're doing here. It is highly appreciated!

I have a question, I was about to publish a Post in your community and I decided to wait a few more days when I read the rules, I understand that non-own content is considered plagiarism, that said, my Post was going to be about indigenous gastronomy of my Country and What is its relationship with world gastronomy, although it is original content because I will design and write it according to my knowledge about it, I do not have all the related images and surely I would have to use some of the internet placing their respective source of course. Would that be okay or would plagiarism be considered as well?

Hi @randomproject123, That would not be considered plagiarism. Quoting with attributes, images with proper sourcing or credit is all good (unless the images are rights managed) i.e You can't use an image from commercial sources, like Getty and just say "source Getty Images" as those images are rights managed. That will get you in trouble.

The other thing we see a lot of is direct translations of posts or Internet articles. Unless it's yours or you have the explicit rights to it, that would be considered plagiarism.

Hope that helps. Feel free to pop into Discord or post more questions here.

To perfect then, because I sometimes take photos from the internet, logically citing them and the writing is entirely my own, it is a summary of all the research that I basically do. I already feel much calmer to post. Thanks a lot :)